Game 1: Mr. I. W. Hardin aka Wayne Hardin - ""Head Football Coach for U.S. Naval Academy"" (born in Arkansas, currently living in California; 32 years old) Game 2: Dorothy M. Fraser - ""Sells Submachine Guns, Pistols, Rifles & Shotguns"" (she is the Sales Manager for Harrington and Richardson, from Worcester, Massachusetts) Game 3: Esther Williams (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Branch Rickey - ""President of New Continental Baseball League"" Game 2: Marilyn Picard - ""Fingerprint Expert"" (from Brooklyn & White Plains, NY) Game 3: June Allyson (as Mystery Guest #2)
Game 1: Henry McFarland - ""Jail Warden"" (at the Hudson County Jail in New Jersey; from Jersey City, NJ) Game 2: Judy Grable - ""Professional Wrestler"" (from Miami, Florida, she began her career at age 18) Game 3: Claudette Colbert (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Glenn Stoneburner - ""Tests Tubas (For Musical Instrument Mfr.)"" Game 2: Barbara Morris - ""Seal Trainer"" Game 3: Garry Moore (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Nancy Weis - ""Fills Orders For World Series Tickets""
Game 1: LCDR M. L. Davison, USN - ""Hurricane Hunter (U.S. Navy Flier)"" Lieutenant Commander Morgan L. Davison flew propeller airplanes into hurricanes for weather research for the U.S. Navy; he uses the Radar Super Constellation airplane; from Jacksonville, Florida) Game 2: Carita Mann - ""Sells Money Belts"" (from New York City, NY) Game 3: George Montgomery & Dinah Shore (as Mystery Guest Duo)
Game 1: Victor Borge (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel is blindfolded) - ""Poultry Farmer (Raises Rock Cornish Hens)"" Game 2: Norman Niblo - ""London ""Bobby"" (Policeman)"" (from London, England) Game 3: Hedda Hopper (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Elfriede H. Germann - ""Stockbroker"" (originally from Munich Germany; currently from New York)
Game 1: Edward Karlson - ""Whaling Captain"" (from Durban, South Africa) Game 2: Edna L. Yates - ""Garbage Collector"" (from Lake Placid, Florida, she is head of their Sanitation Department) Game 3: Gary Cooper (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Mr. R. S. Colley - ""Develops and Makes Space Suits for Astronauts"" (for B. F. Goodrich Company; he is working on the Mercury Project; from Cuyahoga Falls, OH) Game 2: Miss Nancy Guerrieri - ""Men's Barber"" (from Aliquippa, Pennsylvania, she is 16 years old) Game 3: Phil Silvers (as Mystery Guest) He first signs in as Rock Hudson; see notes below Game 4: Marion E. Swink - ""Prints Race Track Programs"" (from New York, and Salisbury, North Carolina)
Game 1: Ann Faulkner - ""Television Cameraman"" Game 2: Lee A. Sullivan, Sr. - ""Makes Ferris Wheels"" Game 3: Harry Belafonte (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: E. A. F. Holm - ""Inspector in Royal Canadian Mounted Police"" (this Canadian Mountie is dressed in full uniform; he is a liaison officer in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada; the panel is blindfolded) Game 2: Birute Macezinskas - ""Makes Lollipops"" (for Barton's Candy Company; originally from Lithuania; currently from Brooklyn, NY) Game 3: Joanne Woodward & Paul Newman (as Mystery Guest Duo, and they sign each other's names)
Game 1: Juanita Kidd Stout - ""Judge"" (from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania) Game 2: Robert C. Wishart - ""Makes Horse Liniment"" (from Conway, Massachusetts) Game 3: Fabian (as Mystery Guest) (also known as Fabian Forte)
Game 1: Tom Dooley, M.D. (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel is blindfolded) - ""Doctor / Runs Jungle Hospital in Laos"" (John gives Dr. Dooley a donation check for $5,000) Game 2: Diana Tessler - ""Makes Wigs, Toupees & Hair Pieces"" (for Hairline, Inc.; she is left-handed) Game 3: Walter Brennan (as Mystery Guest #2)
Game 1: Grace Lake - ""Window Washer"" (from Byram Township, Sussex County, New Jersey) Game 2: Robert Sullivan - ""Grows Christmas Trees"" (in Sheerland Forest; from Berks County, Reading, Pennsylvania) Game 3: Richard Rodgers & Oscar Hammerstein II (as Mystery Guest Duo) Game 4: James Wilfong - ""Shoes Horses"" (from Ann Arbor, Michigan)
Game 1: Frances Parrish (Frances Knight Parrish) - ""Director of the United States Passport Office"" (she states that she'd like color photos for the passport photos; from Newport, Rhode Island) Game 2: George B. Hansburg - ""Inventor & Manufacturer of Pogo Sticks"" (he discusses the origin of the pogo stick; from Walker Valley, New York) Game 3: Art Carney (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Perian Conerly - ""Writes Football Column For Newspapers"" (she is the wife of Charley Conerly, a famous football quarterback; he comes out after her game; he was given the prestigious Jim Thorpe Award today; from Clarksdale, Mississippi; see notes below) Game 2: Sandy Qackett - ""House Painter"" (from Wellington, Kansas) Game 3: Arlene Dahl (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Gerald Behn - ""Secret Service Agent (Guarded President Eisenhower on Recent Trip)"" (from Virginia) Game 2: Hazel Williams - ""Sardine Taster"" (from Bangor, Maine) Sardine Taster Game 3: Maureen O'Hara (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Sal Russo - ""Complaint Adjuster for Dept. Store"" (for Saks 5th Avenue Department Store; from New Rochelle, New York)
Game 1: Norma Brooks - ""Dental Assistant"" Game 2: Henry H. Swartz - ""Sells Tranquilizer Pills for Dogs"" Game 3: Tom Poston (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Mr. Chan Wu Nam - ""Superintendent of Korean National Police"" (He signed his name in Asian characters. This is an educated guess as to the spelling.) Game 2: Connie Clark - ""Monkey Keeper for Research Project"" Game 3: George Jessel (as Mystery Guest
Game 1: Evelyn I. Franke - ""Chiropractor"" Game 2: John E. Lingo, Jr. - ""Sells Flagpoles"" Game 3: Jack Paar (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Sister Mary Christina - ""Dentist"" Game 2: Gedney Tuttle - ""Pickle Packer"" Game 3: Nelson Eddy (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Don L. Brown - ""Director of Physical Education at Women's College"" Game 2: Thelma Wagner - ""Makes Horse Blankets"" Game 3: Julie Andrews (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Judy Joye - ""Professional Skin Diver (Search, Salvage, Instruction, Etc.)""
Game 1: Fred E. Pfister - ""Chief Timer for Winter Olympics"" Game 2: Jo-Ag-Quis-Ho (As written in his Native American language.) AKA Orrin Lyons - ""Designs Valentine Cards"" Game 3: Peter Lorre (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Cordelia Sharp - ""Motorcycle Cop"" Game 2: Lin Brown - ""Runs Marriage Bureau (Matchmaker)"" Game 3: Charles Laughton (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Tobias Cohen - ""Sells Used Aircraft Carriers, Battleships, Cruisers, Etc.""
Game 1: Page Wightman - ""Livestock Auctioneer"" Game 2: E.V. Haytis - ""Sells High Explosives"" Game 3: Peggy Lee (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Graham Liens (pronounced ""Lyons"") - ""Sells Baby Carriages"" Game 2: Morna Campbell - ""TV Newscaster"" Game 3: Gisele MacKenzie (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Richard Hanley - ""Elizabeth Taylor's Secretary"" Game 2: Carolyn Herron - ""Exterminator"" Game 3: Kathryn Murray & Arthur Murray (as Mystery Guest Duo)
Game 1: Vivian Sirratt - ""Cattle Photographer"" Game 2: William Taylor - ""Makes Square Manhole Covers"" Game 3: Shelley Winters (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Louise Eammons - ""Census Taker (Took Census at Homes of our Panel)"" Game 2: Nick Padilla - ""Designs Maternity Clothes"" Game 3: Jane Fonda (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Edward Fenn - ""Butler""
Game 1: John Daly - ""U.S. Income Tax Examiner"" (No relation to the host of WML!) Game 2: Oliver Leese - ""Raises Cactus"" Game 3: Jack Lemmon (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Alex Pompez - ""Baseball Scout (S.F. Giants)"" Game 2: Emma Stachewicz - ""Breaks Eggs (10,000 Per Day)"" Game 3: Jonathan Winters (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Robert Hewitt - ""Makes Ladies' Garters"" Game 2: Grace Luce - ""Paperhanger"" Game 3: Bob Cummings (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Gloria Bale - ""Trapeze Artist"" Game 2: Charles ""Chic"" Gaylord - ""Makes Holsters for Guns"" Game 3: Laurence Harvey (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Betty Rode - ""Butcher"" Game 2: D. Ronald Adams - ""Baker Wedding Cake for Princess Meg"" Game 3: Gertrude Berg (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Manny Schoedes - ""Candlestick Maker""
Game 1: Bonnie Harrington - ""Kindergarten Teacher"" Game 2: Edward R. Blime - ""Racetrack Starter"" Game 3: James Cagney (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: PFC Mary Luksis - ""Dental Technician for West Point Cadets"" Game 2: John Torp - ""Runs Flea Circus"" Game 3: June Allyson (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Sue Mandel - ""Trombone Player""
Game 1: Mary Ann Messiek - ""Justice of the Peace"" Game 2: Charles T. Reece - ""Inspects Atlas Missiles"" Game 3: Jane Wyman (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: John W. Mullhen - ""Sells Hay""
Game 1: Mrs. Gladys Carter - ""Twists Chewing Tobacco"" (for Liggett & Myers Tobacco Company; she twists 1200 tobacco ""twists"" per day and has been employed by them for 33 years; Gladys is the mother of Don Carter, a professional bowler; from St. Louis, MO) Game 2: Mrs. Dorothy Logan - ""Gives Out Parking Tickets (N.Y.C. Police Traffic Dep't ""Meter Maid"")"" (salaried; from Brooklyn, NY) Game 3: Bobby Darin (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Miss Jeanne Parr - ""Television Weather Girl"" (for station WNHC in New Haven, Connecticut; salaried; from Stamford, CT)
Game 1: Carol Bonnaviat - ""Judo Instructor"" Game 2: Thomas Hull - ""Burns Money"" Game 3: Van Johnson (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Jean Ward - ""Barmaid in English Pub"" Game 2: Len Barron - ""Sells Bridal Veils"" Game 3: Ingemar Johansson (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Charles McCoy - ""Mosquito Exterminator"" (from Morris County, New Jersey)
Game 1: Arthur Mercate - ""Beer Salesman"" Game 2: O.T. Gillett - ""Cowboy"" Game 3: Elaine May & Mike Nichols (as Mystery Guest Duo) Game 4: Mitch Shapiro - ""Puts Sticks in Popsicles""
IDENTICAL TWINS NIGHT! In honor of the 26th Annual ""International Twins Association"" Convention, all of the regular contestants are identical twin sets who are dressed alike.
Game 1: Miss LaVelda Rowe & Miss LaVona Rowe - ""News Photographers"" Game 2: Miss Barbara Harker & Miss Virginia Harker - ""Sell Worms"" Game 3: The Sound of Music (as Mystery Guest Cast) Game 4: Bernard Ross & Howard Ross - ""Dentists""
WML will again have a ""twins night"" on EPISODE #847 on January 29, 1967.
Game 1: Lou Puckett - ""Plumber"" Game 2: Pauline Nesselrodt - ""Makes False Tails for Horses"" Game 3: Shelley Berman (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: Liza Redfield - ""Conducts Orchestra for Broadway Show ""The Music Man"""" Game 2: Arthur Abramson - ""Manufactures Sleeping Bags"" Game 3: Jerry Lewis (as Mystery Guest)
Game 1: William C. Westmoreland & John Davidson - ""Superintendents: West Point & Annapolis"" aka General William Westmoreland & Admiral John Davidson Game 2: Nancy Pomroy - ""Lobster Fisherman"" Game 3: Zsa Zsa Gabor (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Maureen Napier - ""Tour Guide on Sightseeing Boat (New York City)""
Game 1: Sherrylyn Patecell - ""Rockette (Dancer at Radio City Music Hall)"" Game 2: Syd Simons - ""Make-Up Artist (Did Speakers at GOP Convention)"" Game 3: Myrna Loy (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Frank Prudenti - ""Bat Boy for N.Y. Yankees""
Game 1: Arnold Palmer - ""Professional Golfer and Masters and National Champion"" Game 2: Michael Jackson - ""Rock ‘N' Roll Disc Jockey"" Game 3: Dina Merrill (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Doris Mossotto - ""Dog Catcher""
Game 1: Laurence N. Snyder - ""Head Coach U.S. Olympic Track Team (Coach - Ohio State University)"" Game 2: Albert W. Hall - ""Sells Chicken Feed"" (See notes below) Game 3: Jesse Owens (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Don Bragg - ""United States Army Private"" (Due to time constraits, Don did not sign in or play an actual game. Mr. Daly brought him on stage to introduce him, and had the panel make some ""free wild guesses"" as they used to do in the 1950 to 1955 episodes. See notes below.)
Game 1: Robert M. White & Joseph A. Walker - ""X-15 Rocket Plane Test Pilots (Set Speed and Altitude Records)"" Game 2: Patricia Hewson - ""Pizza Pie Tester"" Game 3: Buddy Hackett (as Mystery Guest) Buddy signed in as ""Maralyn Monroe"". (Oops, he misspelled Marilyn!)
Game 1: Robert, Theodore, Allan & Arthur Specht - ""Registered Nurses"" Game 2: Pat Hayes - ""Rides Brahma Bulls in Rodeos"" Game 3: Bette Davis (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Anne Maciag - ""Zipper Tester""